On April 1 2009, the High Court of Kuala Lumpur, in delivering the judgment in the case of Illinois Tool Works, Inc v Pendaftar Cap Dagangan, Malaysia [2009] 1 LNS 507 (Illinois), provided proper guidelines for the Registrar in issuing acceptance or objections when examining a trade mark. Illinois is a Fortune 500 company, founded […]
Malaysia - Registrar’s Discretion in a Trademark Application: Judicial Principles should Prevail over Arbitrariness
Illinois Tool Works, Inc v Pendaftar Cap Dagangan The Registrar of Trade Marks has a general discretion to refuse to register a trade mark which satisfied all the positive conditions laid down by the Trade Marks Act. However, that discretion must be exercised judicially on reasonable grounds which are capable of being clearly stated, and […]
Singapore - SingTel Strikes First Blow In “Mio” Trade Mark Suit
In a recent judgment, the Singapore High Court upheld the validity of Singapore Telecommunications Ltd's (SingTel) trade marks and accordingly acquitted SingTel of trade mark infringement against Mitac International Corporation's (Mitac) registered trade marks. Background Mitac is a company incorporated in Taiwan and is in the business of providing computed products, internet appliances, wireless communication […]
India - Government Use Of Patents Debated
A patent confers exclusivity upon the patentee to exploit an invention and to produce, sell or import the patented product or process for a limited period. However, there are some limitations to this exclusive right, such as research exemptions, providing some information to the authorities and the Bolar exception. The Indian Patents Act, 1970 incorporates […]
Malaysia - McDonald’s Loses Trade Mark Mcbattle
The Court of Appeal has unanimously upheld an appeal by McCurry Restaurant (KL), allowing McCurry to use the prefix Mc in the name of its restaurant. In this case, McDonald’s Corporation’s claim against McCurry at the High Court was premised on the fact that McCurry is liable for passing-off for using the prefix Mc in […]
Well-Known Marks Are Protected In Singapore
The concept of well-known marks was first introduced in Singapore when the Trade Mark Act was amended to provide for the protection of well-known marks in 1999. As such, even if a well-known mark is not registered in Singapore, the owner of a well- known trade mark may take action to ensure protection of their […]
Thai Court Rules Against Department of Intellectual Property
In the recent Thai case of DCON Productions PCL v Department of Intellectual Property (Case No. 48/2008), the Central Intellectual Property and International Trade Court (CIPITC) dealt with a suit by the Plaintiff against the Department of Intellectual Property (who was the Defendant in the case) in respect of the decision made by the Defendant […]
India - Exclusive Fashion Gets Copyright Protection
A recent case at the Delhi High Court has dealt with the overlap between copyright and design protection and its application to the fashion industry in India. The questions addressed by the case were, firstly , whether drawings or sketches are artistic works and, secondly, whether the object or commercial intention be tested while applying […]
Malaysia - How To Take Action Against Counterfeits
Owners of trade marks face a difficult choice when they learn that their products have been counterfeited and are being sold in Malaysia. The recommended course of action is to conduct an investigation by an authorized private investigator to find out who is producing or selling the counterfeit product and obtain a trap purchase. Through […]
Malaysia - Trade Description Order for trade mark infringement
In Malaysia a trade mark owner can enforce his rights in a number of ways. A effective means of enforcement against an infringer of a trade mark or a person liable for passing off, would be to obtain a Trade Description Order (TDO). This is provided by virtue of section 16 of the Trade Description […]