In a recent patent infringement case in Singapore, the courts dealt with the issue of validity of the patent in suit. The case was between Muhlbauer AG (the plaintiff) and Manufacturing Integration Technology Ltd (the defendant). The plaintiff is a company incorporated in Germany. It is the registered proprietor of Singapore patent number 117982 entitled […]
Malaysia - Court Nullifies Trade Description Order
In Malaysia a trade mark owner has the possibility of enforcing his rights by way of trade description order wherein an order of court is obtained to declare an infringing brand as false trade description, which allows infringing products to be seized by the authorities and the infringers prosecuted. However the importance of obtaining an […]
Singapore - Copyright Infringement Confirmed As Copyright Infringement Suit of a Virtual Map Runs Its Course
A long running legal saga has now come to an end with the Singapore Court of Appeal's decision that Virtual Map (VM) had no further right to appeal against the High Court's decision finding them guilty of infringing the Singapore Land Authority's (SLA) copyright in it's street directory vector data and it's address point vector […]
Appeal Procedures in Vietnam for Industrial Design Rights In Place
On 19-20 December 2007, the National Intellectual Property Office (NOIP) of Vietnam in co-operation with the EC-ASEAN Intellectual Property Rights Co-operation Programme, ECAP II organised a two-day seminar in Hanoi. This comprehensive training with highlights on Opposition and Appeal Procedures on Trade Marks and Industrial Designs managed to gather about 100 participants of the Inspectorate […]
India - Trade Mark Holder Scores Absolut Victory
V&S Vin & Spirit Aktiebolag (V&S), the owner of the Absolut trade mark, one of the most well-known and reputed brands in the world for spirits and luxury goods, filed a civil suit in India against Bangalore based pharmaceutical company Pharmed and one of its subsidiaries (Pharmed) for infringing, passing off and diluting its well-known […]
Thai Design Patent Revoked For Lack Of Novelty
The Supreme Court of Thailand has dealt with the issue of novelty of a design patent in the case of Little Bell Co., Ltd v Pongsawad Tiananon (Case No. 2824/2007). In this case, the Plaintiff, a corporation known as Little Bell Co. Ltd took legal action and contested the validity of the Second Defendant's product […]
Malaysia - Functional or utilitarian characteristics of an article of manufacture are not protectable under passing off law
Alfa Laval ( M) Sdn Bhd v Ng Ah Hai & Ors [2008] 5 MLJ 344 The Plaintiff, Alfa Laval (M) Sdn Bhd, a manufacturer and supplier of plate heat exchangers and plate under the brand 'Alfa Laval' applied for an injunction to inter alia restrain the Defendants from passing off imitation plate heat exchangers […]
Malaysian Patent - Interim Injunction Granted in Malaysia Based on American Cyanamid principles
In the case of Aventis Farma SA (m) Sdn Bhd v Rohibul Sabri bin Abbas @ Megat & Anor [2008] 3 MLJ 451, This case is based on the selling generic version of docetaxel trihydrate (hereinafter referred to as "DT") According to the Plaintiffs, the Defendants had infringed their Malaysian Granted Patent MY-118481-A (herein after […]
Malaysia - The Sale Of Goods Bearing A Trademark Over The Internet Is Recognized As Use Of The Trademark In Malaysia
In a recent decision the Malaysian High Court in the case of Abercombie & Fitch Co. & Anor V Fashion Factory Outlet KL Sdn Bhd & Ors [2008] 4 MLJ 127, held that sale of goods bearing a trademark over the Internet or via a website is recognized as use of the trademark. In the […]
The Test For Interlocutory Injunction In Trademark Infringement and Passing Off Tightens in Malaysia
In the recent Malaysian decision of Sanbos (M) Sdn Bhd v Tiong Mak Liquor Trading (M) Sdn Bhd [2008] 3 MLJ 100, the High Court dealt with the test of what would be sufficient to grant an interlocutory injunction in trademark and passing off matter. The Plaintiff was the registered proprietor of the trademarks "CLUB […]